Cameron Slater, writer of the biting political blog Whaleoil, faces court on January 5th., charged with breaching name suppression orders. He posted pictorial clues identifying people in two high-profile sexual offence cases.
It's the first time a NZ blogger's been taken to court, rather than just getting a growling. But Slater says he'll defend his actions because the laws protecting people's identities need changing: NZ's suppression laws were last reviewed six years before the Internet was invented! Also, he says, because websites like his are not owned in or run from New Zealand, it's unclear which countries' laws bloggers should adhere to - a nice try but I suspect the country in which you're actually writing will have the authority.
Those in/around journalism a while know the boundaries and, if unsure, common sense makes you pull back a bit. If you're a political blogger like Whaleoil, then you DO know.
Slater claims the Police have made QUOTE: "a small (small?!?) issue of a breach of name suppression into a global debate about the rights and wrongs of criminals being able to hide their details when the victims are often publicly named and their pictures shown for all the world to see."
I see two issues here:
(1) Criminals and accuseds often get seemingly-unfair name suppression (for the sakes of their reputations, families, careers etc) while their victims stand penniless, cower in fear or lie in hospital beds.
(2) Whaleoil knowingly breached legal name suppression orders.
Issue (1) needs serious/urgent overhaul because, yes, it SUCKS!
Issue (2) smells like an experienced blogger being too clever for his own good...and that sucks too!
PS: 06 Jan.2010 - Slater appeared in court yesterday and has been remanded on bail without plea for two weeks. Watch this space (or his...)!
PS: 12 Jan.2010 - Couldn't leave well-enough alone: while on remand Slater's done it again, this time naming a former politician accused of indecent assault, and using computer coding to mask the text! He thinks it's his right to do so, because he feels the law is wrong. Whaleoil is the one who's wrong: until the outdated law is changed, he is breaking it. Simple as that. What a wanker!!
New Zealand time:
Current Visitors:
Welcome, Readers!
From 4624 locations in 185 countries - please leave a comment!
Hit Pic: 15 Aug.
Scroll to the bottom...
Search Tags:
actors and movies
adventure
advertising
alcohol
art
blonde
books and authors
cars
children
computers
consequences
conservation
conversations
cruelty
DOC
driving
email
environmental
feeling foolish
food and wine
gay
Google
health
heritage
hotty
internet
language
maori
meanings
media
memories
military
motivation
music
networking
New Zealand
nuclear
pharmaceuticals
planes
plus-size
politics
pollution
PR
quirky
recession
recycling
religion
responsibility
rumours
satellites and space
scams
science
ships and wrecks
social impact
spies
sport
students
techno
trojans worms and viruses
TV
unclear instructions
weather
whales
GENEALOGISTS!
Imagine finding on-line, details of your ancestor's grave, in a cemetery on the other side of the world! Then being able to get a photo of the headstone for free! Find out more about the
GRAVESTONE PHOTOGRAPHIC RESOURCE PROJECT: how you can benefit... how you can help!
Saturday, December 26, 2009
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
1 comment:
A reciprocal reply to your visit to my blog. We both agree that Slater is foolish and will cop it from the law, and the law itself needs looking at, because some people are hiding behind it right up to semtencing.
Post a Comment